CD Review: Enescu / Mussorgsky / Borodin (Alexander Krichel, piano) Berlin Classics 0302072BC

The combination of piano works by Enescu and Mussorgsky is a new one on record, though both works included here have been recorded several times before. Therefore, this recording by Hamburg-born artist Alexander Krichel faces stiff competition from the start.

Enescu’s Second Piano Suite was written in 1903 and consists of four movements. Given Enescu’s love of J. S. Bach’s music it is unsurprising that he followed the Baroque model of a dance sequence – a majestic Toccata, a noble Sarabande, a slow Pavane and a lively Bourrée.

Even though it is missing the opening Toccata and is captured in less-than-ideal sound, fans of Dinu Lipatti may still want to track town this historic recording of the suite. Lipatti’s compatriot, Aurora Ienei, recorded the suite in 1981 for the Romanian Electrecord label (it was licenced to the Olympia label and second-hand copies can be occasionally tracked down. Although Ienei’s touch is sure, the boxy acoustic does little to enhance her piano’s sound. Luiza Borac’s 2003 recording for Avie was hailed as ground-breaking at the time and followed extensive research into the autograph scores of Enescu’s piano oeuvre. This led to many errors in the printed versions being corrected; the recording very much continues to stand the test of time. Matei Varga turned in a more than creditable recording for Naxos. Christopher Falzone’s recording for the Sisyphe label rather flew under the radar and is intent on sounding more like Bach than anything else. Heard alongside the best of these alternatives (Borac and Varga), Krichel’s recording sounds somewhat cool and detached, even though it is technically very well played indeed.

Mussorgsky’s Pictures at an Exhibition might be the more famous of the two works on this release, for many that might be a draw. The work might be better known in orchestral incarnations – most often Ravel’s – but the piano original is worthy of exploration. Mikhail Pletnev (Virgin Classics) gets to the heart of the work with insightful characterisation of the Promenade across its several incarnations. Krichel’s performance, although interesting, finds less variety in this connective tissue that runs through the work. Where Krichel does score though is in a few of the individual tableaux that form the exhibition. The missing element, though, is the same one missing from his Enescu: feeling for the music. With that there might be more palpable weight and Russianness in his overall conception.

The slender two minute Nocturne from Borodin’s Petite suite provides an addendum that rounds out the recording in a pleasant manner.

The recording captures the piano faithfully. The interview with Krichel, though, is maybe rather more questionable. When all is considered though, this is a recording that, although possessing positives, does not quite lead the field in this repertoire.